Best Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo Recipe to Try

If you’re craving a seafood treat that bursts with rich, creamy flavor and classic New England charm, the Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo is your go-to recipe. This delicious dish combines tender lobster meat with a perfectly balanced butter mayo sauce, creating a luscious filling that’s both comforting and indulgent. Whether you’re hosting a summer lunch or looking for a special twist on a sandwich, this recipe is easy to follow and guarantees a crowd-pleaser every time.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Simple yet Luxurious: Uses fresh lobster and classic ingredients for a fancy flavors without any fuss.
• Perfect Balance: The butter mayo sauce brings richness without overpowering the sweet lobster meat.
• Quick Prep: Ready in under 30 minutes, perfect for busy days or last-minute gatherings.
• Customizable: Easy to tweak for dietary preferences or special occasions.

Ingredients You’ll Need

These few but essential ingredients work together to give your Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo its fluffy texture, bright flavor, and irresistible appeal. Each component plays a role in elevating the dish to seafood perfection.

• Fresh lobster meat: The star ingredient, ideally cooked and chopped bite-size for tender, juicy bites.
• Mayonnaise: Provides creaminess and a subtle tang to complement the lobster.
• Unsalted butter: Melted and mixed in for depth and smooth, rich flavor.
• Lemon juice: Adds a refreshing brightness and balances the richness.
• Celery (optional): Offers a crisp texture and mild vegetal note when finely diced.
• Chopped fresh chives or parsley: For a fresh, herbaceous finish and vibrant color.
• Top-split hot dog buns or brioche rolls: Lightly toasted for soft yet sturdy sandwich holders.
• Salt and pepper: Simple seasonings to enhance all the flavors.

Variations for Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo

Feel free to personalize this classic Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo recipe to suit your taste buds or dietary needs. These variations make it easy to bring a new twist or accommodate what’s available in your kitchen.

• Spicy Kick: Add a dash of cayenne pepper or hot sauce to the mayo for a little heat.
• Avocado Blend: Mix mashed avocado into the mayo for a creamy, healthy fat variation.
• Light Version: Substitute Greek yogurt for mayonnaise to keep it lighter and tangier.
• Herb Infusion: Incorporate dill or tarragon for a different herbal aroma and flavor profile.
• Gluten-Free: Use gluten-free buns or lettuce wraps for a low-carb, gluten-free option.

How to Make Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo

Step 1: Prepare the Lobster Meat

Start with cooked lobster meat, either fresh or thawed, ensuring it’s cut into bite-sized chunks. If using whole cooked lobsters, carefully extract the meat from claws and tails, removing any shells.

Step 2: Make the Butter Mayo Mixture

In a small bowl, melt the unsalted butter and allow it to cool slightly. Combine the melted butter with mayonnaise, fresh lemon juice, salt, and pepper. Stir gently until smooth and well blended.

Step 3: Add the Lobster and Extras

Fold the lobster meat into the butter mayo mixture, taking care not to break up the chunks. Add finely diced celery and chopped herbs if desired, mixing lightly to combine all ingredients.

Step 4: Prepare the Buns

Lightly toast top-split hot dog buns or brioche rolls in butter until golden brown. The slight crispness helps support the creamy lobster filling and adds delicious flavor.

Step 5: Assemble and Serve

Spoon generous amounts of the lobster butter mayo filling into each toasted bun. Serve immediately for the best texture and flavor.

Pro Tips for Making Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo

• Use Fresh Lobster: Fresh or high-quality cooked lobster meat makes all the difference in taste and texture.
• Melt Butter Properly: Let the melted butter cool slightly before mixing to prevent the mayo from separating.
• Don’t Overmix: Gently fold the lobster in to keep chunks intact and maintain a nice texture.
• Toast the Buns: Butter-toasted buns add crunch and buttery flavor that perfectly complements the filling.
• Chill Briefly: Refrigerate the lobster salad for 10-15 minutes before serving to let flavors meld without making it soggy.

How to Serve Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo

Garnishes

A sprinkle of fresh herbs like chives, parsley, or dill adds a pop of color and freshness that elevates the rich lobster mixture beautifully.

Side Dishes

Pair with classic summertime sides such as crisp coleslaw, kettle-cooked chips, or a bright cucumber salad to balance the richness of the lobster roll.

Creative Ways to Present

Serve lobster rolls on mini slider buns for parties, or scoop the filling atop avocado halves or crisp lettuce leaves for a light twist that looks stunning on any table.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Store leftover lobster rolls filling in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 days. Keep buns separate to prevent sogginess before serving.

Freezing

It’s best not to freeze lobster salad with butter mayo as the texture and flavor can degrade; instead, freeze plain lobster meat separately if needed.

Reheating

Since this recipe is served cold or at room temperature, avoid reheating lobster rolls. Instead, prepare fresh buns and assemble just before serving.

FAQs

Can I use frozen lobster meat for Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo?

Absolutely! Just make sure to thaw it fully and pat it dry before mixing to maintain the perfect texture and flavor.

Is butter mayo healthier than traditional mayo alone?

Butter mayo combines the creaminess of mayonnaise with the richness of butter, adding flavor but also more calories; you can lighten it by using yogurt-based alternatives.

Can I prepare Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo in advance?

Yes, you can prepare the lobster filling a few hours ahead and store it chilled, but assemble the rolls right before serving for best freshness.

What type of bread works best for Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo?

Top-split hot dog buns or soft brioche rolls are classic choices, offering a soft yet sturdy base that holds the filling well.

Are there any good side dishes that pair well?

Crisp, fresh sides like coleslaw, potato chips, or a light green salad perfectly complement the rich lobster rolls.

Final Thoughts

If you want a seafood sandwich that feels like a special occasion but is effortless to make, give this Lobster Rolls Butter Mayo recipe a try. Its creamy texture, bright flavors, and buttery richness combine into a comforting dish you’ll want to share again and again. Dive in, savor every bite, and enjoy a true taste of coastal luxury right in your own kitchen!

Print